Insights from the Industry Disruptors podcast

The Harsh Truths of Property and Finance: Part 1.

Episode 7

In this explosive first part of the Industry Disruptors episode "The Harsh Truths," Ajay Nayyar and Jordanne Whiley MBE pull back the curtain on the bizarre, frustrating, and sometimes outright ridiculous things that happen behind the scenes in the world of mortgages, underwriting, and property transactions.

From nonsensical underwriting questions to bizarre client behaviour, this episode hits hard with real-life examples that show the chaos mortgage professionals deal with daily. Whether you’re a seasoned property investor or someone trying to understand the back-end of financial services, these stories are eye-opening—and sometimes jaw-dropping.

When Common Sense Doesn’t Apply

One underwriter demanded evidence for a rental payment that was literally the first transaction on a clearly labelled bank statement. Another wanted proof a client paid themselves—despite the work being completed and evidenced in full. These aren’t just rare occurrences; they’re painfully common.

And let’s not forget the case where a top UK bank underwriter asked who “Lisa” was on a client’s bank statement—completely unaware that LISA refers to a Lifetime ISA.

The Problem with Surveyors and Solicitors

Surveyors come under fire, too—rightly so. One valued a property at £4 million, despite saying on-site it was worth £6 million, simply because “the lender would prefer it.” Another admitted to fabricating a valuation because they couldn’t access part of the building.

Solicitors aren’t exempt from scrutiny. One tried to delay completion by inventing new requirements after the lender had released funds. Another claimed title splits were “illegal”—a laughable misunderstanding for any professional.

Client Chaos: The Other Side of the Coin

As Ajay and Jordanne make clear, they don’t just deal with industry incompetence. Clients, too, can be difficult. One printed all documents and posted them instead of emailing PDFs, only to send emails later with other documents. Another submitted a passport photo—with a vape in hand.

While these moments often spark laughter, they also reflect how poorly understood the adviser role can be. As Jordanne puts it: “We care more about the deal than some clients do.”

Advisor Fatigue and the Need for Realism

This episode doesn’t just serve up laughs; it addresses real problems. Unrealistic client expectations and a lack of appreciation for the complexity and effort behind securing finance are daily struggles for advisers.

Ajay says it best: “We exist to make a client’s life easier—to simplify the process. But some treat us like we’re nothing in the process.”

Part 2 Coming Soon

This is only the beginning. Part 2 will dive deeper into surveyor overreach, lender red tape, and more unfiltered insights into a broken but still navigable system.

Share

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

This article was produced by the team at Hearthstone Mortgages, led by Ajay Nayyar (CeMAP), Founder and Managing Director, and Jordanne Whiley MBE (CeMAP, CeRER, PhD), Office Manager and Senior Adviser. With deep expertise in specialist lending and a client-first approach, Hearthstone is dedicated to helping property investors and homebuyers make smart, informed decisions.

Learn more about the Hearthstone team.

Industry Disruptors Podcast

Podcast Hosts

Ajay is the Founder and Managing Director of The Hearthstone Group and established Hearthstone Mortgages in 2019 after excelling in the UK mortgage advisory space. He is an expert in mortgages, bridging loans, and protection, with a personal property portfolio and extensive speaking experience at investor and lender panels. Driven by a passion for empowering clients, Ajay continues to expand the Hearthstone brand, delivering invaluable knowledge. Outside of work, he is an award-winning actor and producer with over 20 projects to his name.
Jordanne is the Office Manager and Senior Adviser at Hearthstone Mortgages. An award-winning expert in mortgages, equity release, commercial property, bridging, development finance, protection, and will writing, Jordanne's dedication to helping clients achieve their dreams is unparalleled, reflected in her glowing reviews. Beyond her advisory role, Jordanne is a 4x Paralympic medalist and 13x Grand Slam tennis champion, bringing her Olympic-level ambition to Hearthstone's daily operations.

Speak to our
advisers today

Our friendly advisers are available Monday to Friday, for a no obligation consultation.

Ajay Nayyar
Hearthstone logo

Talk to a Mortgage Expert Today.

Just pop in your details and one of our expert mortgage advisers will personally reach out to help you take the first step.

Fast answers. Friendly advice. Free consultation.